
8:15 p.m. - Forty-five minutes until the debate comes on Channel 12. I consider the pointlessness of live-blogging a taped debate on broadcast television that has already been covered by
Colorado Confidential. I decide to do it anyway.
9:00 p.m. -
Ritter and Beauprez are joined by Libertarian Dawn Winkler, and American Constitution Party nominee Clyde Harkins. Panelists include CBS's Jim Benemann, PBS's Aaron Harber and
The Rocky Mountain News' Stuart Steers.
9:05 p.m. - First question is about how the candidates are different from the current administration. Ritter criticizes Owens for not doing the things necessary to grow Colorado's economy - including marketing the state and improving transportation. Beauprez wastes no time bringing up his business experience. (Ritter 1, Beauprez 0)
9:09 p.m. - Benemann asks Ritter if it's fair to say he's spent too much time in politics. Ritter points out his career as a prosecutor and his work as a missionary.
9:10 p.m. - Referendum C time! Ritter
speaks at length about the good it's done. He seems comfortable in the debate. Has the facts at his fingertips. Lots of specifics. Beauprez tries to get folksy (and buy time) by asking that everyone call him Bob. Then he admits the state needed the money, but claims he could have pulled it out of thin air because he's magic (or something like that). Ritter calls Beauprez for advocating short-term fixes instead of the sensible long-term plan that the voters approved last November. (Ritter 2, Beauprez 0)
9:16 p.m. - Winkler might be a better choice for many Republicans than Beauprez.
9:18 p.m. - Ritter mentions his recently released
plan for the state budget. Beauprez promises he'll put out a budget plan soon. (Ritter 3, Beauprez 0)
9:29 p.m. - Beauprez claims that the illegal immigration crisis is one of the main reasons he "wanted to come home." Good line. But Ritter calls Beauprez for the hypocrisy. Why does a congressman want to become governor, just to turn around and ask congress to do something about illegal immigration? Beauprez mumbles something about Ritter having plea bargained immigrants when he was a D.A. This thing is becoming a walk. (Ritter 4, Beauprez 0)
9:31 p.m. - Ritter stumbles a bit over his support for the Democratic legislature's special session. Beauprez scores one accidentally. (Ritter 4, Beauprez 1)
9:33 p.m. - Beauprez gives a smooth defense of market-driven healthcare. Works his family into the debate very naturally. Ritter talks about how healthcare is a matter of both the hard numbers and of life and death. He scores by praising Republican Gov. Mitt Romney's comprehensive healthcare plan. Call it even. (Ritter 5, Beauprez 2)
9:40 p.m. - Prescription drugs. Ritter has done his homework, talking to all stakeholders. Says we should look at a multi-state drug purchasing plan. Beauprez disagrees, but doesn't have a plan of his own. (Ritter 6, Beauprez 2)
9:43 p.m. - Abortion. I have heard Ritter's speech on this four times now. He gives a very in-depth answer and knows the issue's nuances, but sometimes the more you talk, the worse you sound. Beauprez claims that Ritter can't be pro-life unless he's willing to legislate his morality statewide. Unbelievably, he seems to be trying to tar Ritter with the flip-flop image. Winkler is the only pro-choice candidate on the stage. I can't score this one. If you're deeply pro-life, add one to Beauprez's tally in your head.
9:51 p.m. - Transportation. Ritter is eager to talk about his transportation plan. Beauprez (Mr. Clean Energy!) wants to build a new corridor into the mountains. Not a popular stance, unless you're in the concrete industry. (Ritter 7, Beauprez 2)
9:55 p.m. - Closing statements. Winkler talks about how she's the only candidate who will get government out of the lives of Colorado citizens. Ritter seems very confident talking about his vision for Colorado's colleges, transportation and healthcare. Beauprez talks about his "life experience" and invites us to watch him deal with immigration, literacy and healthcare. Tie. (Ritter 8, Beauprez 3)
10:00 - Wrapping up. I'd say Ritter won the debate. But it was probably closer than my 8-3 (or 8-4, if you're pro-life) score would indicate. Ritter didn't press Beauprez enough on his habit of flip-flopping. Beauprez also came across as having a more inspiring life story than Ritter, which is insane. Consistency and morality are two of Ritter's strong suits. If he can press them even harder next time, he'll score a more decisive win.